I asked all of you (for the fourth time since 2014) to identify the best (or most impactful or memorable) book you’ve read since 2021. Here is Part IV (the final chapter) of your responses.
Jessica Silver writes, “Project Hail Mary by Andy Weir. It was such a surprise and an unending delight. Every one of the very different people in my family adored it. It is smart, funny, thought-provoking, moving, and entertaining.” Rachael Winfree writes, “My favorite book published since 2020 is Calling Bullshit by Bergstrom and West. It’s about why there is so much misinformation in today’s world and how we can use our critical reasoning to detect it.” Lauren Beiley writes, “Foster by Claire Keegan. The author takes a long time to write short novels and distills it down to only the necessary prose, but boy does she convey her characters and themes without a lot of decoration. I think about this book a lot—it’s about a young girl sent to be fostered for a summer with distant relatives.”
Quincy Vale writes, “Around 20 years ago I read Jonathan Strange and Mr Norrell by Susanna Clarke. As a tale of an alternate magical history of medieval and Victorian England (heavily footnoted), the level of detail and the sheer talent of the author shone through the pages and had a profound effect on me. I waited patiently (and then impatiently) and then despaired, because the author was…mute, gone, silent. Just nothing. Finally, about two to three years ago: Piranesi. It’s totally different from Clarke’s first work but another sterling achievement of literary talent. The imaginative story of a passage through trauma is set in endless halls of statuary, and a story of grief, solitude, salvation, and maturation is revealed.”
Josh Vogel writes, “I have to go with Nice Racism by Robin Diangelo, a followup to her bestseller, White Fragility. If you believe that critical race theory is about teaching white children to hate themselves, I suggest you skip to our next classmate in this edition. However, for anyone trying to understand how to be a better white person in America, these are both worthwhile reads. Interestingly, the author herself is white, and her goal (and challenge) is to add a white voice to anti-racist literature with the hope, I think, of getting a better connection and response from white people. A word of warning: If you aren’t prepared to examine your own role in perpetuating racism, you will experience a huge dose of denial and likely even feel insulted. Diangelo’s first book discusses our innately defensive response to the idea that we could be racist. Don’t bother reading the second book until you are comfortable with this concept. Her second book is about how our comfort with the status quo makes us culpable in perpetuating racism. For me, getting past my traditional view of racists as Neo-Nazis or KKK members was essential.”
Mark Sternman writes, “I finally read Ray Bradbury’s Fahrenheit 451 on vacation in Toronto. The power of the narrative and the message of the novel moved me greatly at the time; they seem even more profound in retrospect as repression of freedom of expression has regrettably only increased during the past few years.” Rob Crawford writes, “American Nations: A History of the Eleven Rival Regional Cultures of North America by Colin Woodard. I wanted to understand why smart people in different regions of the United States disagree so vehemently on fundamental issues. Woodard’s brilliant book traces a clear ideological thread back to the culture and circumstances of each region’s first non-Native American settlers. Fascinating stuff.”
—Rob Crawford, 22 Black Oak Road, Weston, MA 02493; crawdaddy37@gmail.com