I asked all of you (for the fourth time since 2014) to identify the best (or most impactful or memorable) book you’ve read since 2021. Here is Part III of your responses.
Christine Smith writes, “The Passage by Justin Cronin. If you like Stephen King-style dystopian fiction, then this is crack for your reader’s brain. My son Matthew was given a few choices for ninth-grade summer reading and I skimmed the first 30 pages of this book just to find out how Cronin decided to end the world. Yup, got hooked. I finished the remaining 920 pages and then bought the rest of the trilogy for a happily occupied summer. Matthew chose Station Eleven by Emily St. John Mandel, which I have also read and would highly recommend.”
Matt Miller writes, “Though it’s been out there for a while, I recently read Tuesdays with Morrie by Mitch Albom. Terrific story. Touching, sad, uplifting. A couple of years ago I grabbed the English AP reading list from my youngest to get some ideas. Just Mercy by Bryan Stevenson is another really great and meaningful true story. How many of us would graduate from Harvard Law School and pursue a career like his?” David Greenberg writes, “I recently revisited all four novels of John Updike’s Rabbit series and feel changed by the experience. I read them in my 20s and 30s, but here in my 50s they mean so much more as I can bring my life experiences to the novels. I heartily recommend re-reading books you enjoyed as a young person now that you know so much more about life.”
Sanda Lwin writes, “One of the best books I’ve read in recent years is The Critic’s Daughter by Priscilla Gilman, a former colleague of mine when we were both English professors at Yale. This is a beautiful and powerful memoir about growing up in New York in the 1970s. Her father, the late Richard Gilman, was a prominent drama critic for Newsweek and The Nation and taught at the Yale School of Drama for decades; her mother, Lynn Nesbit, is one of the foremost literary agents in New York. Their Upper West Side dinner parties were full of literati and intellectuals—from Harold Brodkey to Susan Sontag, Toni Morrison to Bernard Malamud—and it’s against this backdrop that she writes primarily about her complicated and tumultuous relationship with her brilliant father. A really great read.”
Kevin Roon writes, “Being Wrong: Adventures in the Margin of Error by Kathryn Shultz. An incredibly thorough, thought-provoking, and funny exploration of human fallibility by one of my favorite authors.”
Paul Haffner writes, “I finally tackled Moby Dick during the past few months, finishing the weighty tome on an overnight Amtrak out West. I had no idea the tale we know of Ahab’s obsession to vanquish the great whale is likely less than 20 percent of the story—the novel is an anatomy, biology, and history lesson as well. It was a bit of a grind to get underway and it’s not for everyone. If you have any attention deficit issues, don’t dig archaic analogies, or struggle reading language deemed offensive today in historical context, I would stay safely on shore. But if you have a thirst to learn the ways of the whale and the men who hunted them to feed an enormous industry, get ye prepared to join the epic voyage of the Pequod—thar she blows!”
—Rob Crawford, 22 Black Oak Road, Weston, MA 02493; crawdaddy37@gmail.com